Can you set up an experiment?
I Wrote a small a post he got home. All is good, but there is one big BUT. A large part of the comments is absolute offtopic. And then my head visited the absolutely idiotic idea.
What if you now replace the original text of the post is a fake and fit under the existing comments? How to react to Hebraist, waking up in the morning and seeing the text is absolutely crazy news, but it is a serious review?
Of course, to decide on such a step without your approval I can't.
A few hours later, with the support of users of Habrahabr, the above experiment was made.
Under the cut is the post that had been hanging for two hours on the main Habrahabr, and small insights. In advance I want to apologize to those who have accepted it at face value and earnestly commented on the message.
To start with, some text:
At the end of the town's past in a small town Kovacova Ukraine was quite resonant at the local scale event. The mayor, being in an alcohol intoxication, I brought down 15-the summer teenager. How typical this kind of news, this information is posted on the local website, collected a huge number of comments and attracted considerable attention (unlikely to be the whole story had developed, whether as a driver "mere mortal").
A couple of days people vyskazal their outrage about the act of the mayor. At this time, the guy was in the hospital with a concussion, and in General "verbal protest" did not participate. But a heated discussion received absolutely unexpected continuation! After the condition of the teenager had improved, he began to write on the same site. And told all over town that the accident in an unexpected way affected his ability to think logically. And what is most unexpected — in a good way. The guy discovered his ability to multiply in the mind of a four-digit figures, despite the fact that previously had at school, constant trouble with math.
Digging on the Internet, the teenager found an interesting research by British scientist David Fake, which States that a General opinion that injuries and head injuries have a negative effect on mental abilities is a huge mistake. These studies indicate that injuries to the head (of course, not deadly :) on the contrary improve the functioning of that part of the brain responsible for logical thinking.
Given the huge number of jokes that go around about programmers and their children's head injury, it would be very interesting to know the opinion of abrasheva for this reason.
So, this message has hung in the main page Habrahabr. For three hours, I bravely watched as melts my karma ). Many news was received at face value, in a separate review, I tried to prove that I'm wrong. Once again I want to apologize to these people. And to agree with them — indeed, the study of David Fake is hardly true.
And only two hours later there was a comment that explicitly States that this is a fake, and it specifies the name of the city, and the name "British academic".
Sorry, failed to achieve the purity of the experiment and to answer the main question: do we read the posts, or the focus is initially placed on the review. Unless you can answer — who as...
First to respond to the new text fairly well-known on Habre mecommayou with an angry comment, and the question of how considered, checked, etc. His comments and all that are below, left during the experiment. As an apology plus karma to everyone who took the bait.
Please note that the first comments to this post were written at the stage of discussing the need for a similar trick.
P. S. you know, that nonsense, but the attempt was interesting.
P. P. S. Can transfer in a humorous blog?
Article based on information from habrahabr.ru
What if you now replace the original text of the post is a fake and fit under the existing comments? How to react to Hebraist, waking up in the morning and seeing the text is absolutely crazy news, but it is a serious review?
Of course, to decide on such a step without your approval I can't.
A few hours later, with the support of users of Habrahabr, the above experiment was made.
Under the cut is the post that had been hanging for two hours on the main Habrahabr, and small insights. In advance I want to apologize to those who have accepted it at face value and earnestly commented on the message.
To start with, some text:
At the end of the town's past in a small town Kovacova Ukraine was quite resonant at the local scale event. The mayor, being in an alcohol intoxication, I brought down 15-the summer teenager. How typical this kind of news, this information is posted on the local website, collected a huge number of comments and attracted considerable attention (unlikely to be the whole story had developed, whether as a driver "mere mortal").
A couple of days people vyskazal their outrage about the act of the mayor. At this time, the guy was in the hospital with a concussion, and in General "verbal protest" did not participate. But a heated discussion received absolutely unexpected continuation! After the condition of the teenager had improved, he began to write on the same site. And told all over town that the accident in an unexpected way affected his ability to think logically. And what is most unexpected — in a good way. The guy discovered his ability to multiply in the mind of a four-digit figures, despite the fact that previously had at school, constant trouble with math.
Digging on the Internet, the teenager found an interesting research by British scientist David Fake, which States that a General opinion that injuries and head injuries have a negative effect on mental abilities is a huge mistake. These studies indicate that injuries to the head (of course, not deadly :) on the contrary improve the functioning of that part of the brain responsible for logical thinking.
Given the huge number of jokes that go around about programmers and their children's head injury, it would be very interesting to know the opinion of abrasheva for this reason.
So, this message has hung in the main page Habrahabr. For three hours, I bravely watched as melts my karma ). Many news was received at face value, in a separate review, I tried to prove that I'm wrong. Once again I want to apologize to these people. And to agree with them — indeed, the study of David Fake is hardly true.
And only two hours later there was a comment that explicitly States that this is a fake, and it specifies the name of the city, and the name "British academic".
Sorry, failed to achieve the purity of the experiment and to answer the main question: do we read the posts, or the focus is initially placed on the review. Unless you can answer — who as...
First to respond to the new text fairly well-known on Habre mecommayou with an angry comment, and the question of how considered, checked, etc. His comments and all that are below, left during the experiment. As an apology plus karma to everyone who took the bait.
Please note that the first comments to this post were written at the stage of discussing the need for a similar trick.
P. S. you know, that nonsense, but the attempt was interesting.
P. P. S. Can transfer in a humorous blog?
Комментарии
Отправить комментарий